The Reddit community overwhelmingly praises Charter Club — Macy's house brand — particularly for sheets, duvets, and bedding, with many users reporting products lasting 10 to 20+ years. The consensus is that the value is exceptional when caught on sale, and that cotton bedding items in particular rival much pricier alternatives. A handful of dissenting voices flag inconsistency in non-bedding categories like cashmere and fleece blankets.
Charter Club cotton bedding — especially sheets, duvets, and duvet covers — earns strong BIFL credentials with widespread reports of decade-plus durability and great sale pricing, but non-bedding items like cashmere and fleece show inconsistent quality and are not recommended.
Charter Club sheets and bedding are consistently praised for durability, softness that improves with washing, and excellent value on sale. Multiple commenters report sets lasting a decade or more with no significant wear.
Criticism is limited and mostly applies to non-bedding products; cashmere is called stiff and itchy, and one commenter found the fleece throw degraded poorly compared to L.L.Bean. A few note prices have risen significantly post-pandemic.
A former Macy's bedding department employee said Charter Club and Hotel Collection were the only sheets worth buying there, noting their own Charter Club set still looked nearly new after five years.
One commenter described owning Charter Club flannel pajamas for over 20 years — the fabric never faded or developed holes, only the elastic finally gave out.
A longtime buyer said the 550 thread count Damask Stripe sheets launder beautifully, don't pull or rip, and have generous pockets — and that they're regularly available for around half price on sale.
Someone who owned a Charter Club bathrobe for 20 years noted it still comes out of the laundry looking like new.