Eton

The Reddit community holds Eton dress and casual shirts in very high regard, frequently citing them as a benchmark for quality in the dress shirt category. The primary discussion centers on their durability, wrinkle resistance, and long-staple cotton construction, with many users reporting shirts lasting 10+ years. The main caveat is price — Eton shirts are expensive, which leads many to recommend buying secondhand via eBay or Poshmark.

Eton shirts deliver genuine long-term durability and are widely considered the best widely available dress shirt for longevity, but the high retail price and occasional reports of collar wear and elbow tearing mean buying secondhand and managing care expectations are important qualifications.

Community members consistently praise Eton shirts for exceptional longevity, true wrinkle resistance, and quality fabric construction. Multiple users report shirts lasting a decade or more with proper care, and the brand is frequently named as the top recommendation in dress shirt threads.

• Shirts regularly last 10+ years with proper washing care
• Long-staple cotton fabric is highly wrinkle and wear resistant
• Genuinely non-iron — looks fresh even after long flights
• Retains appearance and shape after years of regular wear
• Strong secondhand value makes them accessible at lower price points
• Considered top-tier 'low-luxury' bang for buck in dress shirts

The most consistent criticism is high retail pricing, which puts Eton out of reach for many buyers. A minority of users report durability issues, particularly collar wear on fused collars and occasional elbow tearing, with mixed customer service responsiveness.

• Retail prices around $150–$300 per shirt are prohibitive for many
• Fused collars can wear out over time, reducing longevity
• Some users report elbow tearing, with inconsistent warranty support
• Similar quality potentially available cheaper via made-to-measure tailors
• Not universally flattering — some find cuts don't work for their build

One longtime user noted they've had certain Eton shirts in regular rotation for over 10 years, pushing back on the common view that dress shirts can't last.

A user who bought around 10 Eton shirts spending thousands reported that three eventually tore at the elbow, and found the brand's customer service unresponsive after the first replacement — a notable dissenting voice against the general consensus.

Someone who bought half a dozen used Eton shirts on Poshmark for $20–40 each called them the best feel and fit of any shirt they'd ever owned, highlighting secondhand buying as the smart entry point.

One commenter with extensive experience across 150–200 shirts noted that while Eton shirts are solid, fused collars wear out and truly top-tier construction requires going made-to-measure from specialist makers.