IBM

329 community mentions · Electronics
Hit or miss
Mention volume by quarter
Mention volume by quarter for ibm202120222023202420252026latest

Summary

IBM commands near-legendary status in the r/BuyItForLife community, built almost entirely on the reputation of its vintage hardware — particularly the Model M keyboard and classic ThinkPad laptops. The Model M is the single most-mentioned product and is treated as the defining example of a BIFL purchase, with units from the 1980s still in daily use. The brand-generic comments reinforce this picture while adding ThinkPad nostalgia, but both sources converge on a critical caveat: IBM's quality legacy belongs to the vintage era, and Lenovo-era ThinkPads are explicitly not considered the same lineage by the community.

Verdict

The high-volume Model M analysis (98 mentions) and the even higher-volume brand-generic comments (270 mentions) agree strongly that vintage IBM hardware — especially the Model M — is among the most BIFL-worthy hardware ever made, warranting a strong recommendation on its own terms. The verdict stops short of 'Strong recommend' at the brand level because the community explicitly warns that IBM's legacy does not extend to Lenovo-era products, and practical friction (PS/2 adapters, noise, modern compatibility) means buyers must go in with clear expectations.

What people love

IBM's vintage hardware is celebrated for extraordinary longevity, repairability, and build quality that modern equivalents rarely match. The Model M keyboard in particular is cited as the gold standard of durable consumer electronics.

  • Model M keyboards reported in daily use after 30–40 years with no failure
  • Buckling spring mechanism widely considered the best typing feel ever made
  • Steel backplate and all-metal construction make keyboards nearly indestructible
  • Vintage ThinkPads praised for tank-like build, drainage channels, and easy repairability
  • Unicomp still manufactures Model M units using original IBM tooling
  • IBM POS and commercial hardware described as military-grade in durability

What people criticize

The primary negatives are practical friction from aging hardware and a sharp quality-decline narrative tied to IBM's exit from consumer manufacturing. Vintage IBM products require workarounds for modern use, and no current manufacturer is seen as a true successor.

  • PS/2 connectivity requires active adapters; passive adapters frequently fail
  • Original Model M keyboards are loud enough to disrupt shared spaces
  • ThinkPad quality declined sharply and noticeably after Lenovo acquisition
  • Unicomp reproductions feel spongier and cheaper than original IBM units
  • Model F keyboards nearly impossible to find; secondhand prices are very high
  • Vintage IBM hardware impractical for modern computing tasks despite durability

What people are saying

Decades-old IBM keyboards are still in daily use — the Model M is treated as the single best example of what BIFL actually means.
The community is emphatic that Lenovo ThinkPads are not IBM ThinkPads; the quality decline after the acquisition is described as sharp and noticeable.
Unicomp gets credit for keeping the Model M alive with original tooling, but veterans consistently say the originals feel better.
IBM POS hardware was described as built like military equipment — the brand's reputation for over-engineering extended well beyond just keyboards.

Product lines

  • IBM Model M Keyboard
  • IBM Brand-Generic (ThinkPad, Model F, POS Hardware)