Momotaro is consistently cited by the Reddit community as one of the finest Japanese selvedge denim brands available, frequently grouped alongside Iron Heart, Samurai, and Pure Blue Japan as cream-of-the-crop options. The community's enthusiasm is genuine and sustained, though nearly everyone acknowledges the significant price premium. A recurring sentiment is that once you own a pair, cheaper jeans feel impossible to return to.
Momotaro represents some of the finest denim craftsmanship available and will outlast mainstream jeans significantly, but the high price, necessary break-in period, and inherent limitations of any denim (eventual wear points) mean buyers should go in with clear expectations.
Commenters praise Momotaro for exceptional craftsmanship, durable heavyweight selvedge fabric, and beautiful fade characteristics that improve with wear. The brand is widely regarded as a benchmark for quality Japanese denim.
The primary caveat is cost — Momotaro regularly retails around ¥30,000 (~$165–200+ USD), and some community members note that no jeans are truly BIFL due to eventual crotch blowout regardless of quality. Fit must be carefully considered before purchasing.
One longtime wearer said that Iron Heart and Momotaro had completely ruined them for other jeans, and they only wished they'd made the investment sooner.
A self-described denim enthusiast noted that their $300+ Japanese denim including Momotaro genuinely lasts longer and ages more beautifully than Wranglers or Nudies ever did, even if no jeans are truly BIFL.
Someone who sold eight pairs of modern Levi's to buy a single pair of Momotaro Japanese selvedge jeans said they had zero regrets about the trade.
A community member who tried the jeans in person described finding Momotaro to be the perfect balance between a great fit and a substantial denim weight that didn't feel cheap — after visiting a shop stocking around ten competing brands.