Squier

The Reddit community broadly agrees that Squier has undergone a significant quality improvement over the past 15-20 years, evolving from instruments widely regarded as cheap junk into genuinely capable guitars worth recommending to beginners and beyond. The Classic Vibe line in particular earns consistent praise for punching well above its price point, with some users noting it rivals Mexican-made Fenders. A few caveats exist around specific sub-lines, QC consistency, and competitive pressure from other budget brands.

Squier guitars — particularly the Classic Vibe and Affinity lines — represent genuinely BIFL-worthy instruments at their price point, but buyers should avoid the Bullet series and starter kits, buy from reputable retailers to avoid shipping damage, and be prepared to inspect or perform minor setup work before playing.

Squiers are widely praised for their dramatic quality improvement over the years, excellent value for money, and the Classic Vibe line specifically is highlighted as a standout. Many users consider them genuinely BIFL instruments, especially with minor upgrades.

• Classic Vibe line rivals Mexican-made Fenders at half the price
• Quality has improved dramatically compared to 80s and 90s models
• Durable enough to gig with, even without modifications
• Upgradeable electronics and hardware extend lifespan and value
• Short-scale models great for learners but usable long-term
• Incredible bang-for-buck ratio at the $200 price range

The main criticisms center on inconsistent quality control, a clear hierarchy within the Squier lineup where Bullet and starter kit models underperform, and some concerns about post-COVID QC drops across Fender's factories broadly. A few commenters also note rising competition from Harley Benton and Yamaha at similar price points.

• Bullet series and starter kits widely considered below BIFL quality
• Some units still need factory setup work out of the box
• Post-COVID QC has reportedly declined across Fender/Squier factories
• Bundled starter pack amps described as poor quality
• Some vintage Squiers considered better built than current models

One highly upvoted commenter noted that Squier used to make genuinely bad guitars, but that modern ones are almost indistinguishable from Mexican-made Fenders in some cases — a remarkable turnaround from their reputation 15+ years ago.

A guitar technician in the thread pointed out that while Squier remains great value, post-COVID QC has slipped across all Fender factories, and recommends playing any guitar thoroughly before purchasing.

A user who regularly gigs and records with expensive equipment mentioned they still play and record with the Squier Deluxe they started on 11 years ago, noting it holds up alongside much pricier instruments.

One commenter observed that a $200 Squier today is leagues ahead of what that money would have bought you in the past, reflecting a broader improvement across the budget guitar market.